Comparisons

Should I restore or replace my hardwood floors?

When solid hardwood can be sanded and refinished, when replacement is the right call, and how a small test patch settles the decision.

Published November 18, 2026 by Floors and Beyond VA

Should I restore or replace my hardwood floors?

Restore if the wood is thick enough and the boards are sound. Solid hardwood can usually be sanded and refinished several times, so scratches, dull finish, sun fading and many stains and dents are fixable. Replace if the wood is too thin to sand, if water or structural damage is widespread, if deep pet stains have soaked into the subfloor or if you want a different material. A small test patch in a closet shows the true wood and settles the question with evidence. Floors and Beyond VA is a family-owned flooring company that has served Northern Virginia since 1987, and we are refinish-first.

Checking thickness

Look at a board edge at a vent opening or a threshold. A professional can measure how much wood remains above the tongue and groove.

Frequently asked questions

Can engineered hardwood be refinished?

Sometimes, if the wear layer is thick enough.

Can I change the color?

Yes. Sanding to bare wood lets you choose a new stain.

When to call a professional

If you are not sure what your floor needs, an in-person look settles it. Schedule an in-home estimate with Floors and Beyond VA, or call (703) 906-5698.

Read the full guide: Should I Restore or Replace My Hardwood Floors?
Learn about our floor restoration service.

This guide was written and published by Floors and Beyond VA — a flooring installation and restoration company serving Northern Virginia, including Fairfax County, Prince William County, Loudoun County, and Arlington County. For flooring questions or a free in-home estimate, call (703) 906-5698.

Free In-Home Consultation

Request Your Free Flooring Estimate

Tell us about your project and we will bring samples to your home, measure with a laser at no charge and walk you through a clear, all-inclusive estimate.

Or Call (703) 906-5698 Or Call (703) 906-5698

Ready to get started?

Get a free in-home flooring estimate in Northern Virginia.

Free Estimate Free Estimate

We Bring the Showroom to You

Shop-At-HomeConvenience

Don't drive all over town. We bring the flooring showroom to you. Book your free in-home consultation today — residential or commercial.

Floors and Beyond VA makes getting new floors easy.

Why Shop at Home

See Your FlooringIn Your Home

Close-up of interlocking black rubber gym flooring tiles in a home gym

The best way to choose flooring is in your own home where you can see exactly how it looks with:

  • Your natural and artificial lighting
  • Your furniture and décor
  • Your cabinets and paint colors

No need to visit crowded showrooms. No pressure from big box stores. Just personalized help from a flooring expert who listens to your needs and recommends options that fit your budget and design goals.

Contact Us
Flooring samples and sample books laid out in a bright living room during an in-home consultation

Our Process

Three Simple Stepsto New Floors

Free consultations, measurements, and pricing—with no surprises.

  1. Step 1

    Free, Personalized Consultation

    Choosing flooring can feel overwhelming. We listen to your needs, help you select the right flooring for your home and budget, and bring samples directly to you—with no pressure.

  2. Step 2

    Free, Expert Measurements

    Our professionals use precise laser measurements on every room—at no charge. We account for closets, transitions, thresholds, and moldings to ensure accuracy and eliminate surprises.

  3. Step 3

    Free, All-Inclusive Pricing

    One price. No hidden fees. Everything included: furniture moving, old flooring removal, new materials, professional installation, transitions, molding, and full cleanup.

Transparent pricing. Expert installation. Local professionals you can trust.

Get a Free EstimateGet a Free Estimate